Once you’ve committed to issuing an RFP, the next step is crafting one that gets you all the information you need to make an informed, strategic decision for your organization. A strong RFP doesn’t just ask about pricing—it asks the right questions to uncover a vendor partner’s capabilities, values, and vision.
What it Include in Your RFP
Start with a clear overview of your organization, your employee population, and your goals for the health center. Then, outline the scope of services you’re seeking—primary care, mental health, occupational health, chronic disease management, etc.
Key Questions to Ask
To truly evaluate a health center partner, include questions that go beyond the basics:
- Clinical Quality: What metrics do you use to measure health outcomes? Describe your approach to managing chronic conditions.
- Patient Experience: How do you measure patient satisfaction? What is your average appointment wait time?
- Technology Integration: Can your platform integrate with our existing HRIS or benefits systems?
- Virtual Care: Do you offer virtual visits? How are they coordinated with in-person care?
- Data & Reporting: What kind of client reporting do you provide? How do you use data to drive improvements?
Health Center RFP Evaluation Criteria
Be transparent about how you’ll evaluate responses. Create a scoring rubric that includes categories like clinical quality, innovation, cost, and cultural fit. This helps ensure a fair and objective process that compares apples to apples.
Core RFP Evaluation Criteria
-
Compliance with RFP Requirements
-
Did the vendor follow all instructions?
- Were all required documents and forms submitted?
-
-
Understanding of the Project
- Does the proposal demonstrate a clear understanding of your needs?
- Are the goals and challenges addressed effectively?
-
Technical Approach & Methodology
- Is the proposed solution technically sound?
- Are the methods and tools appropriate for the project?
-
Experience & Qualifications
- Does the vendor have relevant experience?
- Are the team members qualified and capable?
-
Past Performance & References
- Are there strong references or case studies?
- Has the vendor successfully completed similar projects?
-
Innovation & Value-Added Services
- Does the proposal offer creative or innovative solutions?
- Are there any additional benefits or services?
-
Project Management & Timeline
- Is the timeline realistic and well-structured?
- Are project management practices clearly defined?
-
Pricing & Cost Structure
- Is the pricing competitive and transparent?
- Are there any hidden costs or unclear terms?
-
Risk Management
- Are potential risks identified and mitigated?
- Is there a contingency plan?
-
Legal & Contractual Terms
- Are there any red flags in the terms and conditions?
- Is the vendor compliant with legal and regulatory requirements?
Pro Tip: Ask for Case Studies - Request case studies or client references that demonstrate the vendor’s ability to deliver results. Look for examples that align with your goals—whether that’s reducing ER visits, improving chronic disease outcomes, or increasing employee engagement.
Optional Enhancements
- Scoring Matrix: Assign weights to each criterion based on importance.
- Evaluator Comments Section: Allow evaluators to justify scores.
- Thresholds: Set minimum scores for critical areas (e.g., compliance, experience).
Final Thoughts
A well-crafted RFP sets the stage for a successful partnership. It helps you identify vendors who not only meet your needs, but exceed your expectations. In the final blog post of this series, we’ll explore how to evaluate responses and make the best choice for your organization.
References
- National Committee for Quality Assurance. (2023). Measuring Health Care Quality. https://www.ncqa.org
- Society for Human Resource Management. (2022). How to Evaluate Health Vendors. https://www.shrm.org
- Willis Towers Watson. (2021). Best Practices in Vendor Selection. https://www.wtwco.com
